Costume SuperCenter vs. Party City vs. vs. BuyCostumes: Halloween Costume Stores Reviewed
Browse articles:
Auto Beauty Business Culture Dieting DIY Events Fashion Finance Food Freelancing Gardening Health Hobbies Home Internet Jobs Law Local Media Men's Health Mobile Nutrition Parenting Pets Pregnancy Products Psychology Real Estate Relationships Science Seniors Sports Technology Travel Wellness Women's Health
Browse companies:
Automotive Crafts, Hobbies & Gifts Department Stores Electronics & Wearables Fashion Food & Drink Health & Beauty Home & Garden Online Services & Software Sports & Outdoors Subscription Boxes Toys, Kids & Baby Travel & Events
Costumes Rankings Q&A Coupons Reviews Comparison Grid Directory Articles
Ask a Question about Costumes

Costume SuperCenter vs. Party City vs. vs. BuyCostumes: Halloween Costume Stores Reviewed

Costume SuperCenter is a good choice for those looking for new, cutting edge costumes and quick email response. Party City has unique options for free trick or treating candy as well as supplies for your Halloween party along with your costume. You can actually rent costumes on if you don’t want to buy. BuyCostumes has unique categories of costumes such as maternity.
Covered in this report
Costume SuperCenter — Best Features
Fast email support time with 0-3 hours being the average.
Unique costumes like collector's Captain America.
Best for: Those looking for recent costumes that have come out for this season.
Party City — Best Features
Get free candy for your entire neighborhood.
Entire tab for plus-sized costumes with many varieties.
Best for: Those interested in trick or treating with their costumes. — Best Features
Rent costumes such as deluxe pirate for men.
Costume your pets with outfits such as star wars AT-AT.
Best for: Those who want to rent a really nice costume instead of buying.
Best deal: Extra 20% off Sale Items - [activate coupon]
BuyCostumes — Best Features
Multiple coupon codes for 10% and 15% off.
Maternity costumes available with options from GoGo to pirate.
Best for: Expecting mothers who want their own unique costumes.
Best deal: 15% Off on an Entire Order of Rave Wear - [activate coupon]

Finding the right costume for Halloween is a time-honored tradition. Here are a few stores you can try that will aid in your quest, including a comparison of their various features and advantages.

Costume SuperCenter


Costume SuperCenter claims to be the biggest collection of Halloween costumes for both kids and adults online. They certainly have a lot of options, including many new arrivals if you want a costume that’s very recent and trendy.


  • Coupon Variety-You can get many different coupons for the Super Center, including $10 off just for signing up with your email address. This comes up as soon as you visit the site. Other coupons include 20% off costumes over $20.
  • Free Shipping Deals-You do have to add in coupon codes to get this, but you can get free shipping for US Economy shipments that come out to more than $75 total.
  • Google Trusted Store-Costume Supercenter has a 4.4 rating from Google, plus the $1000 Google protection. They have fast email support time too, with it being 0-3 hours on average.

Party City


Party City has a number of physical locations throughout the country. They actually used to be branded as iParty, until a lawsuit from Apple forced them to change their name.


  • Free Candy for Neighborhood-If you plan on going trick or treating in your costume, or doing that with your children, you can click on the “free candy” link on the main site in order to get a code you can use for free bags of candy when you buy costumes through the site.
  • Extensive Filters-You can click filters on the left of the site to choose for just about anything including age, gender, and exact accessory type. This includes tutus, gloves, kits, corsets, and so on.
  • Free Ground Shipping on Any Order-There’s no minimum for getting free shipping on Party City through their coupon deals. This isn’t in effect all the time, but coupons frequently allow you to get it.


Halloween Costumes has some extra features such as allowing for trade-ins, pre-owned costumes and even renting costumes.


  • Rent Costumes-If you see a costume that you really like but you don’t want to spend hundreds of dollars on it since you’re only planning on wearing it once, you can rent the costume instead in order to pay much less.  Just click on “rental costumes” on the left under where it says “exclusive” to see what costumes you can choose.
  • Pet Costumes-You can even get Halloween costumes for your pets if you plan on bringing them along with you to wherever you’re going. This includes an Imperial Walker, a leprechaun,a king of bones, and many others.
  • Live Chat-If you need help with one of your order, you can hit the green “Live Chat” box in the top right of the main site to get instantly connected to someone who can help.
  • Internet EScurity Certificates-If you’re worried about making purchases on the Internet, this site has both McAfee Secure and TrustE certifications.
  • A+ BBB Rating-Like other sites in this category, HalloweenCostumes has an A+ rating with this consumer watch service, meaning that they handle complaints effectively.



  • Savings Deals-There are a lot of deals on the site like getting 15% off your next order for signing up to a newsletter. There’s also coupon codes for 10% off and free shipping for orders over $75.
  • Maternity Costumes-There’s actually a link for maternity-specific costumes on the main page on the left. This includes the “Funny Mummy” maternity costume, or the Pop Art Comic Super Woman or the Disco Mama one. There are at least 10 in this category. It helps to have specific costumes here, after all.
  • Amazon Payments-You can use this payment type to pay for costumes if you want. Not all sites have this.
  • Live Chat-You can click on this all the way at the bottom where it says “Chat Now” next to “LiveHelp” if you need to clarify something you have a question about on the page.  

Head to Head


After coupons, a men’s collector Captain America costume goes for $360 at Costume SuperCenter. A more simple boy’s Captain American costume goes for $13. A teen girl’s werewolf costume goes for $25 or so after coupons.

Party City has Captain America costumes for boys that go for about $30. The regular adult costumes go for around $50. have many costumes that go for $85 like a deluxe Captain Hook one. The rental usually costs about half, so $42 in this case. A boy’s Captain America costs $40.

Adult Captain America costumes go for $40 on BuyCostumes. The children’s version goes for $32.

Overall, this means that Costume SuperCenter has some of the best prices for costumes like the boy’s Captain America.


Costume SuperCenter has free shipping deals plus a lot of new arrival costumes like a hoodie ensemble batgirl for teens, for example. The site has an A+ rating from the BBB, indicating they deal with complaints effectively.

Party City has their free candy deals, and they also have a wide variety of both costumes and themed party accessories. This makes them a good choice if you’re hosting a Halloween party in addition to looking for costumes for yourself and your family. It’s easy to find a lot of party supplies that all fit one theme so you don’t have to hunt around for many different items in many different locations. has some unique options such as allowing you to put costumes on your pets or else rent costumes that you don’t want to buy. You can even trade in old costumes or purchase pre-owned costumes as well.

BuyCostumes has free shipping coupons if you spend at least $75, just like CostumeCenter. Party City has a blanket free shipping offer with the right code, so BuyCostumes and CostumeCenter are both behind them in that category. Other features include the BBB rating of A+, though many of the other sites also have this rating. But still, it’s comforting to have anyway.

Additional Information Coupon: Extra 20% off Sale Items - Activate
BuyCostumes Coupon Code: SHIP49 - Free Economy Shipping on Orders Over $49 - Activate
BuyCostumes Coupon Code: EMCRAVE - 15% Off on an Entire Order of Rave Wear - Activate
BuyCostumes Coupon Code: EMCMARDI - 20% Off Everything - Activate
Need an answer?
Get insightful answers from community-recommended
in Costumes on Knoji.
Would you recommend this author as an expert in ?
You have 0 recommendations remaining to grant today.
Comments (0)